[ Back to the listing ] [ Post Reply ] [ Help ] [ Search ]
[ List All Forums ]
| Posted By: on: 08/29/2000 23:05:35 EDT
Subject: RE: Gettysburg and should Meade have persued Lee?
Well you guessed it by the title, I am the son of Jim TNO. My dad suggested that I bring my question before you folks so here goes..
Should Meade have persued Lee more vigoroously? Or was the AOP just as badly mauled as the ANV and that trully prevented it from doing so!
And if the AOP had chased the ANV and caught it BEFORE it got to the river, does the war end there as the ANV is destroyed?
M. Hawthorne (bluelady)
Sorry if I'm late on this reply, but I just got back from a trip...This aspect of the Gettysburg Campaign has always facinated me...why was Lee allowed to escape?...I'm familiar with most of the reasons generally given - new leadership, fatigue, casualties, etc. etc...However, it would seem to me that even with minimal cavalery recon, Meade & Co. must have known the the ANV had to cross SOME river at SOME time...leaving half of the forces on one side and half on the other (unless my math is wrong)...doesn't that leave the AOP with an opportunity to inflict a serious hurt on the ANV??? It's one thing to divide your forces in the face of a superior enemy to fight a force in detail, it's quite another to divide your force with its back to a swollen river...I must be missing something....AAROGON
See I told ya Steve that you would get some realllly gggggooood input from these folks...
Thanks to everyone! Ok my thoughts on this...
He has lost at least three corp commanders, one dead and two badly wounded. And then a lot of his middle command structure is in dissarry from KIA's to badly wounded.. A number of key units torn to pieces (read the Iron Brigade as a prime example) and his Calvary needs a serious rest and refit..
Very good point that we do tend to forget about..... Hmmmm The ANVs command structure was just as shot to pieces as the AOPs maybe even more so especially in the middle commands, ie at the brigade, regimental level, with brigades run by captains and regiments by sergants.
your humble servant,